Then said Jesus to the crowds and to his disciples, “The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat; so practice and observe whatever they tell you, but not what they do; for they preach, but do not practice. They bind heavy burdens, hard to bear, and lay them on men’s shoulders; but they themselves will not move them with their finger. They do all their deeds to be seen by men; for they make their phylacteries broad and their fringes long, and they love the place of honor at feasts and the best seats in the synagogues, and salutations in the market places, and being called rabbi by men. But you are not to be called rabbi, for you have one teacher, and you are all brethren. And call no man your father on earth, for you have one Father, who is in heaven. Neither be called masters, for you have one master, the Christ. He who is greatest among you shall be your servant; whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted.
In recent years, Wesley Huff has become something of an Internet phenomenon. Engaging, articulate, and charismatic, he has arguably become “one of the most famous and influential Christian apologists in the world.”
Certainly he has a sizable audience online. Social Blade records the subscriber count on his YouTube channel at over one million, with his content having generated until quite recently as many as 84 million views daily.
And just like that, it has come crashing down, and Wes Huff’s Internet fame has quickly turned into Internet infamy.
Why did he fall? He was discovered to have plagiarized at least some of his work, some of it dating back years, and some of it more recently.
In the world of academics, research, writing, and creative endeavors, there are few greater sins one can commit. As defined by the Encyclopedia Britannica, plagiarism is “the act of taking the writings of another person and passing them off as one’s own.” The definition likens plagiarism to forgery and piracy—plagiarism is fundamentally the theft of someone else’s intellectual efforts.
Nor is there any real doubt that Wesley Huff plagiarized and expropriated the work of others. He has admitted as much, and has acknowledged that what he did was wrong.
Wesley Huff sinned.
Scripture is quite clear on the imperative of honesty and integrity in all the ways people deal with each other. Leviticus 19:35-36 commands the use of only honest weights and measures. Earlier in that same chapter we are commanded by God never to deal falsely with nor lie to each other. These commandments are reiterated in Deuteronomy 25:13-16.
In Luke 16:10, in the Parable of the Dishonest Manager, Jesus warns us that “he who is faithful in a very little is faithful also in much; and he who is dishonest in a very little is dishonest also in much.”
In Acts 5:1-11, Anani′as and his wife Sapphi′ra lied to the Apostles about how much they had received from the sale of property, pretending to donate the entire proceeds while actually holding back some for themselves. The Holy Spirit struck them both dead for their deceit.
Wesley Huff has been dishonest. Wesley Huff has lied. Wesley Huff has sinned.
Wesley Huff is enduring consequences for his dishonesty. Peterson Academy, which had paid Huff to create an instructional course for them, has chosen to distance themselves in defense of academic honesty and integrity. Traffic on his YouTube channel has collapsed. An Internet darling has become an Internet pariah.
What should we make of his downfall? Is Wes Huff being “cancelled”, as some will argue? Is an online outpouring of rage and condemnation a just and appropriate response to Huff’s misdeeds, or is it excessive and even “unchristian”, as others suggest?
Should we forgive Wesley Huff? Jesus admonishes Peter in Matthew 18 that he should forgive his brother “seventy times seven” times for wrongs inflicted, telling His followers the Parable of the Unforgiving Servant to remind them (and us) that a failure to forgive others their trespasses will result in God refusing to forgive our trespasses against him.
We do well to forgive Wes Huff. He has sinned. He has confessed that sin. At present at least, he appears to be repentant and contrite.
Repentance is what God asked of the Israelites in Isaiah 1:18. God again calls Israel to repent in Ezekiel 18:30-31. In Jeremiah 3:12-13 God calls on Israel to acknowledge their sins, acknowledge their guilt, and return to Him.
Wes Huff has at least outwardly acknowledged his sins. Wes Huff has at least outwardly acknowledged his guilt. Wes Huff has at least outwardly acknowledged that what he did was wrong, and that he stands in sore need of forgiveness.
Will Wes Huff recover his Internet following? That seems unlikely.
Will he ever be awarded the doctorate for which he has been studying? That also seems unlikely, as some of the work he has done towards that doctorate is now tainted by his plagiarism.
Will he ever be paid in the future to create instructional content on Christian theology and Scripture? Petersen Academy initially sought to stand by Huff, supporting him in pushing back against what some see as “cancel culture”, but they decided that position was not tenable. It is difficult to see Petersen Academy or any other entity buying content from Wes Huff.
We do well to forgive Wes Huff, but we should not pretend that forgiveness will erase his sins, or allow him to carry on as before.
We do well also to remember that Wes Huff is human. He is as we all are—fallen and sinful. As the Apostle Paul sagaciously reminds us in Romans 3:23, “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.”
Wes Huff has sinned. Those who outed him for his sins of plagiarism have themselves sinned. Those who have raged against his plagiarism have themselves sinned. Those who have unsubscribed from his YouTube channel have sinned.
You have sinned. I have sinned.
Sin is our reality. Sin is a universal constant in a constantly changing world.
As all of us have sinned, as all of us are sinful, we do well also to remember that all of us are at best impoverished and imperfect interlocutors of God’s Word. No matter how well-intentioned we are in ministry, we make mistakes in ministry. No matter how earnestly we desire our church communities to be righteous, our church communities are corrupt and not righteous.
Pastors are sinful. Priests are sinful. Popes are sinful. In this regard Wes Huff is no different—and more than a few pastors have themselves been caught up in accusations of plagiarism.
When we consider the sinful state of all men, it is not hard to understand why Jesus teaches us to call no one on earth “rabbi” or “Master”. When we consider the sinful state of all men, it is not hard to understand why Jesus admonishes us to “beware the leaven of the Pharisees.” When we consider the sinful state of all men, it is not hard to fathom why Jesus warns us to be on guard against false prophets and false teachers, likening them to “ravenous wolves.”
Has Wesley Huff been as a ravenous wolf? That is a decision each of us must make in the sanctity of our own minds. Every person who encounters a Wes Huff video, or even hears of this plagiarism scandal, must decide for themselves how grievous a sin it is, and how to regard Wes Huff’s work in light of the scandal. We are called by God to judge right and wrong for ourselves; the closing verse of Judges makes that clear, even as it warns us our judgement can go horribly wrong.
What Wes Huff has demonstrably been is a part of Internet “influencer” culture. He has been, for better or worse, a Christian “celebrity.” There are more than a few pastors, evangelicals, and Christian apologists who are part of that culture.
To the extent that Christian “influencers” inspire people to turn their lives back towards God, what they do is arguably a good and productive ministry. We should be thankful for every new believer their efforts help bring forth.
Yet we should never forget that all influencers are still only human, the same as all pastors, all priests, all popes, and as Wes Huff. We should never forget that every ministry is only as good as its fidelity to God’s Word. We should never forget that we are called to do good works on this Earth to glorify God, not ourselves.
We should never forget that we are only the messengers. Christ is the Message.
Wes Huff must now live with the infamy of plagiarism. Wes Huff must now live with the possibility people will no longer listen to him and no longer be inspired by him. Wes Huff must now answer for his sins—as must we all, eventually.
Wesley Huff’s ministry may be at an end, but ministry itself will continue. Messengers to carry the Good News of Jesus Christ, His Crucifixion and His Resurrection, will continue. To the extent that Peter’s Proverbs is a ministry, even with my small following, it will continue.
Messengers will come and go, but the Message remains eternal. Christ remains eternal.
Messengers do not matter. Christ matters. God matters. God’s Word and God’s Law matter.
The good and true witness of believers will not be diminished by Wes Huff’s fall into Internet infamy. The good and true witness of believers cannot be diminished by Wes Huff’s fall into Internet infamy.
We do well to forgive Wesley Huff for his sins. We do well to pray for Wesley Huff. We do well also to remember that, even at the height of his celebrity, Wesley Huff was still only the messenger. Even in the depths of Wesley Huff’s infamy, Christ is still the Message.



I’ve never heard of this guy, just as I’ve never heard of 99.9999+% of the people on our planet. It doesn’t matter. What matters for each soul on earth is your relationship with God, your peace with yourself, your liking and loving of yourself, and your goodwill toward mankind.
People today forget that the Internet has only existed for a few decades, and it is an aberration of normal human interaction. I see young people so extremely stressed out because they aren’t getting enough “likes” on social media. It’s sad. Meanwhile, what’s happening in the real world is this: sometime after you turn fifty you become invisible. No one notices you exist as you enter a room or walk past them on the street. No one cares that you exist. And you know what? This can be very liberating. It’s now just you and your relationship with God. You are free from social judgement. And God becomes your sufficiency.
There are only two reasons I spend time on Substack: to get reliably factual news - such as from All Facts Matter - and to interact with a few people whom I truly like, such as yourself, Peter. These two things I find to be priceless, just as having real friends in the real world is priceless. The current young generations of people are someday going to realize this and abandon social media as the artificial pressure cooker that it is.
Maybe this Wes Huff guy will also realize that it is his relationship with God that matters, not Internet fame.
Bless you, as always, Peter.